In the 1950 book Ontario In Your Car, authors John and Marjorie Mackenzie noted that Kitchener, with a population of 40,000, was one of Ontario's most progressive cities. Their description of Kitchener highlighted the substantial meals at the Walper Hotel, three golf courses, four movie theatres (open continuously from one o'clock every day, except Sunday), and the presence of an Eaton's department store on King Street. However, they were not able to suggest places of entertainment other than the movie theatres and golf courses because in 1950, the only museum in Waterloo County belonged to the Waterloo Historical Society, housed in the basement of the Kitchener Public Library.
It was timely then that in 1952, local radiologist Dr. A.E. Broome, nicknamed "Dusty", travelled to Europe and happened upon the Nederlands Openluchtmuseum in Arnhem, Holland. Broome realized that in the booming post-war years, Ontario's rural landscape, farms, and small towns were quickly disappearing to urban sprawl and that nowhere in Ontario was the province's rural history being preserved as he had seen at the European open-air museum.
Upon his return to Kitchener, Broome lobbied various organizations and levels of government for support for his idea to create the "Ontario Rural Life Centre", dedicated to the celebration of agriculture and industry. Broome received support from many local agencies and organizations, and small pledges of funds from some of the area municipalities.
He also visited Williamsburg, Virginia, Old Sturbridge Village in Massachusetts, and the Farmers' Museum in Cooperstown, New York, to learn from their open-air museum villages. At the time, there were no open-air museums in Ontario, although Black Creek Pioneer Village and Upper Canada Village were both in the planning stages.
In their written request to the Honourable F.S. Thomas, Minister of Agriculture, the proponents of the museum noted that "Mr. John Root, M.L.A., North Wellington, in seconding the motion for adoption of the Speech from the Throne, suggested that the Government of Ontario should consider the construction of a Pioneer Memorial to take the form of an early nineteenth century crossroads and farm community. . . . It is known, however, that the Premier [Leslie Frost], and several of his Ministers, including yourself, have seriously and favourably considered Mr. Root's suggestion."
They also requested the "Government of Ontario proceed with the construction of an all-Ontario Pioneer Museum at an early date [in Waterloo County] . . . with appropriations from the departments of Agriculture, Education, Wildlife, and Planning and Development."
It is obvious from their written proposal that while there was substantial local support for the museum, it was hoped that the Province of Ontario would assume the greater portion of start-up and capital development costs. However, this would not come to pass, and while the Province did commit funds to the museum project, it was only a small amount, which in turn resulted ultimately in a narrowing of the museum's focus from all of Ontario to Waterloo County.
The first board of directors was a diverse group including representatives from Galt, Kitchener, Waterloo, Waterloo County, the Federated Women's Institute, the Ontario Library Association, the Pennsylvania German Folklore Society, the United Empire Loyalists, the Teachers' Federation, the Kitchener Horticultural Society, the Ontario Federation of Agriculture, the Kitchener Chamber of Commerce and Junior Chamber of Commerce, Junior Farmers, the Ontario Educational Association, and the Waterloo and Ontario Historical Societies.
The organization was incorporated under the name 'The Ontario Pioneer Community Foundation' in 1956.
Doon Pioneer Village opened one year later on June 19, 1957, with the raising of a barn. The name Doon was chosen to reflect the nearby village, begun in 1834.
The Galt Evening Reporter noted on opening day that "Blunt, toil-calloused hands and pale fingers more used to pushing pens joined together in answering the call of 'yo ho, heave' at Doon yesterday as the old time custom of barn raising was relived. ... The foundation has elaborate plans for the development of the piece of land, which will one day become a complete monument to the men and women who cleared the first paths for modern Canada."
On opening day, City of Galt Alderman Mel Moffat, later to become site administrator, summed up the reasons behind the creation of the village - "if [we] failed to grasp the opportunity to preserve the past now it would go forever."